CodePen

  • Probably good with just "You can't role=navigation on a "

  • <ul>

  • "Verbosity in screen readers is a choice" seems more like a draw.

  • Maybe it could read "More verbose in screen readers", or get combined with "Announcing the number of items in the list can be helpful"

  • "The spec doesn't care" also seems like a draw.

  • fair points, will adjust